Duchesne Alum Brings Original Play to the Stage

For Andrew Sweeso ’17, this year’s Duchesne fall play began with a practical problem and ended with something entirely original.
Unable to find an existing production that fit the school’s cast, performance space, and Halloween-week schedule, Sweeso decided to write one himself.
The result was The Weird Sisters, a full-length play inspired by themes and characters from Shakespeare’s Macbeth, but set among modern high school students dealing with college decisions, busy schedules, relationships and, unexpectedly, newfound supernatural powers.
“This is the first full-length work that I’ve developed and finished and presented to the public,” Sweeso said. “This was a bit of a leap for me, for sure.”
Sweeso is no stranger to writing or the Duchesne stage.
While a student, he took creative writing classes and wrote several scripts for Acting class and Duchesne’s student-written and -directed one-act plays. He also directed two one-acts of his own.
That interest continued after graduation.
Sweeso earned both his bachelor’s and master’s degrees in English from Saint Louis University. While an undergraduate, he took multiple creative writing classes, published a short story in SLU’s undergraduate creative writing journal, and later served as an editor for the publication.
In graduate school, his writing shifted more toward academic and professional work, including a published article.
Still, The Weird Sisters marked something new.
The idea began forming at the start of the summer.
With the fall production scheduled for the week of Halloween, Sweeso and fellow director Brad Benne ’03 initially looked for an existing play that fit the season. They also needed something flexible enough to accommodate an uncertain cast size after several experienced actors had graduated.
Eventually, Sweeso realized the most practical solution might also be the most creative one.
“Honestly, the most practical way to do it ended up being writing it,” he said.
Sweeso began brainstorming around mid-June, using Macbeth and other works by Shakespeare as inspiration.
The first version did not last long.
He scrapped his initial outline, created a second one, and brought it with him on a family trip to Europe. That version met an even more unusual fate.
“I left that outline in the back of a taxi,” Sweeso said.
So he started again.
The third attempt became the foundation for The Weird Sisters. Sweeso began writing the script in mid-July and spent the following weeks revising it, reworking characters, and connecting different storylines.
The script was not fully settled until roughly a week before auditions.
For Benne, reading the finished product came with some initial uncertainty.
“As I read through I was truly impressed with how good it was, the story, the characters, and the nods and ties to Shakespeare. It was all really good and honestly much better than several other published scripts I read previously," he said.
Rather than retelling Macbeth, Sweeso used Shakespeare’s tragedy as a jumping-off point.
The Weird Sisters follows high school seniors Grace, Kate, and Rose as they work their way through an arduous classroom unit on Macbeth. Their lives become considerably more complicated when they suddenly discover they have become witches themselves, gaining the ability to summon ghosts, transform people into animals, and perform other supernatural feats.
Beneath the comedy and supernatural elements are some of the same questions that run through Shakespeare’s play, including how people respond to power, fear, guilt, and uncertainty about the future.
The story was also written specifically with Duchesne in mind.
Sweeso designed the script so it could work with as few as five actors doubling roles if necessary. He created smaller roles for newer performers and larger parts that could challenge more experienced students.
He also wrote the characters with the voices of real teenagers in mind.
Sweeso said that after teaching several particularly talkative classes, he began intentionally listening to the way his students spoke.
“I’m like, ‘Okay, this is kind of the way they talk,’” he said. “As I was writing characters, I tried to phrase the dialogue in a way that I could hear my students’ voices while I was doing it.”
That approach helped give the actors something they could make their own.
Madeline Magers ’30, who played Ms. Porter, was performing in her first Duchesne production.
“It was one of the best things I’ve been able to be a part of,” Magers said. “I had a fantastic time with everyone, and I felt it was a place where I could be myself. I was also able to make the character my own since it’s never been played by another.”
That opportunity was unique to the production.
Unlike most high school plays, there was no previous performance to reference and no established interpretation of the characters. Every role was being brought to life for the first time.
The original script also created an unusual dynamic for the directors and actors.
“It’s not every day that a director of a high school play has the luxury of talking to the playwright and getting into their thoughts too,” Benne said. “If I didn’t exactly know what the intent of a line was, I could simply ask Andrew and in turn better help the actors understand as well.”
Sweeso also wrote with the Duchesne Performing Arts Center in mind.
Recent upgrades to the theater’s lighting equipment gave him opportunities to imagine scenes around different colors, spotlights, and LED effects. At the same time, some of his more ambitious ideas had to change once rehearsals began.
“There’s a difference between what you do when you’re sitting and imagining something in all its glory while you’re writing and then the actual practical reality of making it work,” Sweeso said.
The production ultimately included five different settings, requiring Sweeso, Benne, and the production team to find creative ways to transform the stage.
Benne handled much of the set design, while longtime volunteer John Dultz ’79 helped turn the plans into physical sets. Students painted, moved furniture, and worked alongside adult volunteers to prepare the production.
Some changes came right up until opening night.
“We were literally putting new pieces on the wall two hours before opening,” Sweeso said.
For Eleanor Kamer ’30, who played Joey Lawrence, some of her favorite memories came from those moments surrounding the performance itself.
“What I most enjoyed about the play was the times when I wasn’t acting,” Kamer said. “Behind the scenes, or just all of cast and crew getting ready, so much funny stuff had happened. In all, I made some really great memories, and I can’t wait to continue making more.”
Benne said one of the most rewarding parts of the production was watching Sweeso guide something he had created through every stage of the process.
“Throughout the casting, the rehearsals, costume, set and technical design, and even all the way down to song choices, I enjoyed seeing Andrew so passionate throughout the process,” Benne said.
He was equally impressed with Sweeso’s willingness to seek feedback on something so personal.
“When you have a work like this that you put so much work and effort into, it may be hard to ask others for their opinion, but Andrew always welcomed input and feedback,” Benne said.
That willingness to revise is something Sweeso also emphasizes to his own students.
As an English teacher, he encourages students to talk through ideas, present them to others, and give themselves space to rethink their work before considering it finished.
The process of writing The Weird Sisters reinforced those same lessons.
“There were a lot of scenes that just didn’t work,” Sweeso said. “There were scenes that I just cut.”
For Sweeso, those lessons also connect back to his own time as a Pioneer.
“The teachers who worked here when I was a student, many of whom still work here, made all the difference for me when I was preparing for college and adult life,” he said.
As a first-generation college student, Sweeso said the transition to college and the process of finding his vocation were not always easy. He credits Duchesne with giving him a strong foundation for both.
“Our faculty has been blessed with teachers who are masters of their subject and passionate about what they teach,” he said. “They modeled the love for learning and writing that I try to share and model with my students today.”
It is a mindset Sweeso hopes young writers will carry with them as well.
His advice is simple: read widely, write often, and be willing to fail.
“Submit your work to journals and contests, even if you know it’s a long shot,” he said. “Failure is an essential part of writing.”
He also encourages students not to dismiss writing assignments that may seem unrelated to their creative goals.
“The more you write, and the more variety you have in your experience as a writer, the more material and skill you’ll have to draw on when inspiration actually strikes,” Sweeso said.
Even after the final performance, he still sees room to revisit The Weird Sisters.
Because the play was created specifically for Duchesne’s students and performance space, Sweeso is unsure whether he will eventually try to publish it. Doing so could require another round of revisions to make the production easier for other schools to perform.
For now, he plans to give the script some time before deciding what comes next.
“I’m going to let it sit in a drawer for a few months at least,” Sweeso said. “Then we’ll go from there.”
Whatever happens next, The Weird Sisters gave Sweeso something he had never experienced before: the opportunity to watch a full-length story that began in his imagination take shape through actors, sets, lights, and the collaboration of the Duchesne theater community.
Benne was grateful to be part of that process.
“I was truly honored to be a part of the production and see it come together from the ground up,” he said, “and I am proud of Mr. Sweeso for his hard work and dedication.”